Blackout Bowen hands India $825,000 for building solar panels

admin
By admin
14 Min Read

by David Hughes, Executive Director, Menzies Research Centre

Last week the Department of Climate Change gave a university in India $825,200.35 to train Indians to build solar panels.  The tender was not open to Australian organisations.  The Department used an exemption for “procuring outside an Australian territory for consumption outside an Australian territory”. Taxpayers’ money for anything labelled climate or renewables has run out of things to buy in Australia and gone looking abroad.

https://www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/chris-bowens-expanded-solar-panel-scheme-a-complete-waste-of-time-energy-expert-warns-amid-reliability-concerns/news-story/325ae0745c52069ce3c06cce551fff18

The Government’s renewables crusade is at least conducted in the open, where a contract like that can be found and scrutinised.  The same cannot be said of the charitable money that pays for climate activism.
What people do with their own money is their business, but a tax deduction makes every taxpayer a contributor to increasingly radical forms of climate activism.  The charities that campaign on climate are taking in more tax-free dollars every year. Much of it comes from overseas, is relieved of tax twice on the way, and is spent stopping Australian mines and gas projects.
So we have spent the past week following that money.

Stopping things has become one of Australia’s growth industries. In 2024 we published Open Lawfare, which traced how Australia became the world’s capital of litigation against resource projects.  We have now updated our figures.
The 25 environmental organisations named in that report took in $115 million in 2015, surging to $298 million in 2025. Their paid staff more than doubled, from 548 to 1,123.  The clandestine but influential Sunrise Project grew 12-fold, from $5 million to $64 million and the left-wing Australia Institute quadrupled.

The Environmental Defenders Office grew 10-fold, from $2.2 million to $22.3 million.  It exists to run cases against mines, gas fields and the ministers who approve them.
Over the same decade, the charities that care for the poor, the sick and the elderly added staff at half the pace.  The groups that stop things are outgrowing the groups that help.

$1 billion to target Australian resource companies

Climate activism is the only Australian industry that’s booming.  It was revealed this week that a new body, the Australia Climate Impact Initiative, intends to steer $1.1 billion of new philanthropy into climate activism in Australia and our wider region.  It is modelled on Climate Lead, a San Francisco organisation whose showpiece is an American campaign that closed or cancelled about 350 coal plants.  The Initiative describes itself as “fully funded by experienced climate philanthropists”, four of them unnamed.  It has no ABN, no company registration and no charity registration.  It is a project of the Australian Environmental Grantmakers Network, a Melbourne charity which lets its donors claim their gifts against tax. The Network has 230 member foundations which, by its own count, hold $3.6 billion between them.

Most Australians have never heard of the Grantmakers Network.  It presents as a quiet club of philanthropists who like koalas.  But its strategy document reveals a blunter aim: to mobilise philanthropy so that Australia replaces “fossil fuels with clean energy (domestic and exports)”.  Its chief executive warns members that 38 coal projects await federal assessment.  The Network does its work through a members-only “Project Clearinghouse”, a noticeboard where campaign groups pitch for money, and the member foundations choose what to fund. 

Pitches circulated to members in the past three years ask for money to stop:

  • Woodside’s North West Shelf gas extension, which employs 900 people & 1,300 contractors. It has paid more than $40 billion in royalties and taxes since 1984;
  • the Hunter Valley Operations Continuation project, a coal extension initiative responsible for 1,500 jobs & $2.2 billion to $4.2 billion in royalties to NSW;
  • the Narrabri gas project, $3.6 billion of investment & up to $3 billion in royalties and taxes;
  • gas from the Beetaloo Basin, which the Northern Territory Government values at $17 billion and 13,000 jobs by 2040.

A pitch marked “fully funded” paid Greenpeace to try to stop Woodside’s Scarborough gas project before its investors signed off.  Scarborough is a US$12.5 billion project with 3,200 construction jobs.  Another backed the objectors who took the Mount Pleasant coal expansion to the High Court and won last month – it promised 600 jobs & $2 billion in royalties.

The same network has lately set its sights on the banks.  It now funds campaigns to persuade banks to stop lending to coal and gas companies, insurers to stop covering them and superannuation funds to stop investing in them.  Its donors paid to fly the chief executives of Westpac and ANZ to the Tiwi Islands to look at, in the pitch’s words, “their investments in the oil and gas company Santos”.  That is a story for another week.

Influencing elections

The same donors are also being asked to pay for election campaigns.

One of the aims the Grantmakers Network sets for its funders is, in its own words, to “transform the politics”.  The Network and the charities around it are running an electoral operation, subsidised by the taxpayer.  The charities’ returns to the Electoral Commission put a figure on the operation: close to $4 million in declared federal election spending since 2018 by 18 registered charities, before a cent of state campaigning is counted.

In Jess Wilson’s seat of Kew, seven weeks before Victorians vote, Environment Victoria asked the Grantmakers Network’s member foundations for $1,000 each to put “a large digital billboard at Kew Junction” and mini-billboards in front yards across the seat.  The pitch made no secret of its purpose, which was to “put billboards up in Coalition leader Jess Wilson’s electorate and show there’s a political cost to going backwards on energy policy”.

Environment Victoria is a registered charity, and donations to it are tax-deductible.  It has also told the Victorian Electoral Commission that it is receiving political donations for this election; the Commission’s disclosure portal lists one already.  But the Charities Act bars a charity from having the purpose of “promoting or opposing a political party or a candidate for political office”. A charity asking other charities for tax-free money to campaign against a party leader in her own seat offends charity law and electoral law alike.

The enthusiasm for elections is easier to understand once you realise the convenor of Climate 200 sits on the Grantmakers Network’s board.  Simon Holmes à Court has been a director since 2018, and Climate 200 is the principal fundraising vehicle behind the teal independents.  His Trimtab Foundation is one of the Network’s donors and has given Climate 200 $850,000.  In 2022, that board approved legal guidelines that name Climate 200 as a risk to the Network’s charitable status and say that any pitch for a group that “directly supports a political party or candidate” should not be approved.  Yet in February 2025, 11 weeks before the federal election, the clearinghouse carried a pitch titled “Supporting communities through Climate 200”.

The clearinghouse has carried pitches for Labor as well.  In September 2025 the Grantmakers Network’s members received a “rapid response” proposal for $160,000 to “cultivate and strengthen Labor champions” in seven named electorates, with the sitting members listed by seat.  The money was to be paid to the Australian Conservation Foundation, a registered charity, so that donors claim it against tax.

In August 2024, GetUp asked the same members for $150,000 in the lead-up to the Northern Territory election.  GetUp is not a charity, so the pitch asked that donations be made out to Climate Action Network Australia, which is.  The pitch’s second page describes “the get out the vote effort in remote seats” and observes that “Federal Labor needs the bush votes to get elected in the Federal seat of Lingiari”.  Donors were offered a tax deduction for a campaign to get voters to the polls.

Among the Grantmakers Network’s top supporters, at $150,000 or more, is the Paul Ramsay Foundation. Paul Ramsay was a friend of John Howard and a generous Liberal donor. His foundation now supports a network that carries pitches for Labor champions and Climate 200.

Overseas funding and influence

More and more of the money comes from overseas, and the Australian Environmental Grantmakers Network wants it that way.  Its constitution lists among its objects increasing environmental funding “from within Australia and from overseas”.

The Grantmakers Network record the Climate Imperative Foundation as a voting member.  Climate Imperative is a San Francisco foundation chaired by the venture capitalist John Doerr.  It spent US$357 million in 2024 and sent US$15 million of it in grants to “East Asia and the Pacific”.  A foundation of that size now sits inside the Australian network, hears the same pitches as the local members and can fund them directly.

No register in Australia is told how much funding arrives from overseas.  We have counted what we can from the American foundations’ overseas filings: at least $66 million has been paid to Australian climate and environmental groups since 2018, and not one dollar of it had to be declared here.

One of these dollars is worth following from start to finish.  It is deducted from income tax in the United States on its way into a foundation.  The foundation’s grant to Australia counts towards the five per cent it must give away each year to keep its exemption.  When the grant lands with an Australian charity that has deductible gift status, the local donors who top it up claim their share against tax as well.  By the time a billboard goes up in Kew or a barrister rises in the Federal Court to stop a gas project, that dollar has been excused from tax twice, on two continents, and no Australian law requires anyone to say where it began.

Which brings us to the question nobody has yet asked.  If a San Francisco foundation can sit inside an Australian charity network and fund campaigns to close Australian coal and gas, what stops a foundation in Beijing doing the same?

Every Australian mine that is stopped is a gift to a Chinese competitor.  Our charity law cannot tell the difference between a philanthropist and a competitor, because it does not ask.

Three remedies come to mind, and the simplest is disclosure: charities that take money from overseas could be required to say so, above a threshold, in the annual statement they already file.  Foreign foundations that fund political advocacy here could be brought within the Foreign Influence Transparency Scheme, which today captures a lobbyist for a foreign government but not a billion-dollar foundation funding campaigns against Australian industry.  And the charities regulator could be asked whether a charity that solicits billboard money against a named party leader still has the purpose its registration assumes.

The Grantmakers Network calls its members-only platform a clearinghouse, and the name is exact.  It is where the money is cleared of tax, cleared of disclosure and cleared of accountability, before it is pointed at the industries that pay for everything else.
Menzies warned in 1942 against living “as if somewhere there was somebody else’s wealth and somebody else’s effort on which we could thrive”.
Every dollar aimed at stopping an Australian industry should have to say where it came from.


Source link

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *