Manning-Led Report Urges Western Provinces to Form Accord Demanding Constitutional Reforms

admin
By admin
8 Min Read

Western provinces should pursue greater autonomy within Canada, coordinate their demands for federal concessions, and work toward constitutional reforms rather than separation, according to a new report co-chaired by former Reform Party leader Preston Manning.

The report, titled “The Best Path Forward for Alberta and the West Under Current Circumstances,” was released Nov. 17 and outlines five recommendations for increasing Western Canada’s influence within Confederation. It follows Alberta’s Oct. 19 referendum, in which roughly 75 percent of voters supported remaining in Canada rather than pursuing a process toward separation.

The recommendations stem from the Alberta and the West Assembly, a two-day virtual conference held Sept. 19 and 20 and co-chaired by Manning and former B.C. premier Gordon Campbell. Sponsored by the Manning Foundation for Democratic Education, the assembly examined growing dissatisfaction in Alberta and other Western provinces with Canadian federalism and competing proposals to address those concerns.

The report summarizes the assembly’s discussions and recommendations, which the foundation sent to federal and provincial politicians representing Western constituencies. It also invited the politicians to indicate whether they agreed or disagreed with the proposals and suggest changes.

“These steps, some which can be carried out in parallel and others in sequence, represent ‘the best path forward for Alberta and the West under the present circumstances,’” Manning said in a Nov.17 news release.

Strengthening Provincial Sovereignty

The first recommendation urged Western provinces to “strongly and vigorously pursue the development of provincial sovereignty within (not separate from) Canadian confederation.”

The proposal received the strongest support of any put to a vote at the conference, according to the report.

The report recommended strengthening Alberta’s authority in areas under provincial jurisdiction, expanding its influence in shared areas such as agriculture, immigration and the environment, and urging Parliament to adopt legislation respecting provincial sovereignty.

“Equality of provinces should be a characteristic of a federal state, but Alberta does not enjoy equal status constitutionally with that of Quebec,” the report said, describing the situation as a “fundamental flaw” requiring correction.

Pumpjacks draw oil out of the ground near Olds, Alberta., on July 16, 2020. (The Canadian Press/Jeff McIntosh)

Pumpjacks draw oil out of the ground near Olds, Alberta., on July 16, 2020. The Canadian Press/Jeff McIntosh

Increasing Pressure on Ottawa

The second recommendation called on Western provinces to make their demands to Ottawa more specific, set deadlines for compliance, and secure visible support from other provinces in advance.

The report said Alberta and Saskatchewan premiers and energy executives had raised more than two dozen concerns with the prime minister over 18 months, with few of their requests granted. Delegates suggested initially presenting Ottawa with two or three specific demands to gauge its response following the referendum.

The report offered examples such as negotiating an Alberta immigration agreement modelled on Quebec’s 1991 accord and eliminating the functional bilingualism requirement for Supreme Court of Canada applicants.

It also recommended submitting draft legislation when requesting federal policy changes and publishing a scorecard showing which commitments Ottawa had fulfilled.

Western provinces should focus on “informing the public, shifting attitudes, generating real leverage,” the report said, while ensuring there are consequences if Ottawa ignores their demands.

The report cited former Alberta Premier Peter Lougheed’s threat to restrict oil shipments to Eastern Canada during disputes over federal energy policies as an example of negotiating leverage.

Examining Pipeline and Carbon Capture Costs

The third recommendation urged Alberta to provide greater transparency about the financial obligations, risks, and potential benefits associated with its November 2025 memorandum of understanding with Ottawa.

The MOU, signed by Prime Minister Mark Carney and Alberta Premier Danielle Smith on Nov. 27, 2025, sets out a federal-provincial energy agreement that supports a proposed privately financed oil pipeline from Alberta to the B.C. coast for export to Asian markets.

The report noted that the proposed Pacific Link oil pipeline and Pathways carbon capture project were linked under the agreement.

Delegates recommended that Alberta release its cost estimates and commercial studies for both projects and commission an independent assessment of potential government grants, tax incentives, guarantees and liabilities before making further major financial commitments.

The report also suggested using the pipeline’s planned spring 2027 open season to determine whether companies would make long-term shipping commitments. It called for disclosing any government incentives that could influence those commitments.

Spring wheat is harvested on a farm near Beausejour, Manitoba, on Aug. 20, 2020. (REUTERS/Shannon VanRaes/File Photo)

Spring wheat is harvested on a farm near Beausejour, Manitoba, on Aug. 20, 2020. REUTERS/Shannon VanRaes/File Photo

Pursuing Constitutional Reform

The fourth recommendation called on Western provinces to develop a “Western Constitutional Accord” outlining their preferred constitutional arrangements for the 21st century. The proposed accord would be presented to Ottawa and other provincial governments as a basis for negotiations.

Delegates called for greater Western representation in Parliament, changes to equalization, constitutional protection for private and provincial property rights, and stronger safeguards for provincial authority over natural resources.

The report also suggested allowing provinces to opt out of federal programs in areas of provincial jurisdiction while receiving financial compensation.

It recommended incorporating selected reforms into the Constitution to prevent future governments from reversing them through ordinary legislation. Delegates also supported closer economic integration among Western provinces as a step toward establishing a Canadian common market.

Cattle stand in a pasture on a farm in Alberta on Nov. 30, 2023. (The Canadian Press/Jeff McIntosh)

Cattle stand in a pasture on a farm in Alberta on Nov. 30, 2023. The Canadian Press/Jeff McIntosh

Uniting the West

The fifth recommendation urged Western provinces to strengthen their bargaining position with Ottawa through cooperation rather than threats of separation.

The report called for “more strongly uniting the western provinces in support of common objectives, and securing broader and deeper public support for those objectives and the measures required to achieve them.”

Delegates recommended sustained cooperation among Western governments and a coordinated public effort to explain their constitutional and policy objectives.

The report also urged governments to begin implementing measures that could proceed immediately while building support for longer-term constitutional changes.

We had a problem loading this article. Please enable javascript or use a different browser. If the issue persists, please visit our help center.

Source link

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *